Movie Reviews

Saving Private Ryan – 4K UHD Blu-ray Movie Review

Synopsis

Seen through the eyes of a squad of U.S. soldiers, the story begins with World War II’s historic D- Day invasion, then moves beyond the beach as the men embark on a dangerous special mission. Captain John Miller must take his men behind enemy lines to find Private James Ryan, whose three brothers have been killed in combat. Faced with impossible odds, the men question their orders. Why are eight men risking their lives to save just one? Surrounded by the brutal realities of war, each man searches for his own answer – and the strength to triumph over an uncertain future with honor, decency and courage. Winner of 5 Academy Awards, this film is celebrating its 20th anniversary.

Secrets Sponsor

Specifications
Paramount
2018 (1998), 2160p with Dolby Vision, Dolby Atmos, Rated R, 2 hours and 49 minutes
1.85:1 Aspect Ratio
Starring: Tom Hanks, Matt Damon, Vin Diesel, Tom Sizemore and Edward Burns
Directed by: Steven Spielberg

Rating

Entertainment:
Video:
Video:
Extras:

Violence: Intense and graphic
Sex: No
Language: Yes

Commentary

Perhaps one of the most viscerally graphic depictions of war put on film, this movie manages to portray the horrors of war and man’s capacity for courage and heroism. This is my favorite Memorial Day movie that I watch every year to remind me of the sacrifice made by the “greatest generation”. A lot of brave men sacrificed their lives in this war and many were 18-20-year olds. I wonder if we could win a war like this with our current generation of young people? In any case, the opening D-Day invasion scene is a bit tough to watch, but thereafter, the movie settles into a rhythm of slogging through the countryside in attempt to find the titular character.

Each of the men ponder the reasoning in risking their lives for a person they do not know. Hanks portrayal of Capt. John Miller is played with a sense of duty and dignity that only he could pull off. The emotional ending still pulls at my heart and leaves me in wonder. How can it be that this movie is 20 years old? The important thing is that the story it tells is ageless. Highly recommended.

Technical

This film got a new 4K scan with a 4K DI with an HDR upgrade to Dolby Vision. The result is a crisp and detailed film that manages to retain the film grain that gives the movie a “old time” feel. The colors are a bit earthy and muted, but the details in the Army uniforms are resplendent. You can see the variations of greens and the fabric weave patterns. Skin tones are excellent throughout and the dirt and facial stubble is seen in all its gritty glory. HDR makes the flames and glints of sunlight really stand out and the increased contrast heightens the depth of field. The sound has always been of demo quality, especially in the battle for the bridge scene at the end. Every gravel crunch, bullet ricochet and explosion are heard in all the surrounds and mains, yet dialog is still intelligible over the din of battle. If you turn the volume up, be prepared to hold onto your couch, especially if your subwoofer is nearby!

Extras

Secrets Sponsor

This 3-disc set contains over 3 hours of extras, including: An Introduction, Looking into the Past, Miller and his Platoon, Boot Camp, Re-creating Omaha Beach, Music and Sound, Into the Breach, Trailers, Shooting War and Making of Saving Pvt. Ryan. The extras are on BD and a BD of the movie is included.

Jim Milton

Jim Milton has been interested in high fidelity since his college years in the late 70's. It was there that he first became interested in classical music. He has been part of choral music, both in opera and oratorio and is an avid collector of classical music from the Baroque through the Romantic periods. He enjoys an occasional night at Boston Symphony Hall or attending an organ concert at Merrill Auditorium in Portland, ME. Currently he is the director of Nuclear Medicine at the North Shore Medical Center, located just outside of Boston. He also serves as an adjunct professor for Salem State University where he teaches a course in nuclear instrumentation. During his leisure time, he enjoys listening to his music collection and an occasional movie with his wife of 30+ years. Living on the longest stretch of sandy beach north of Boston offers him plenty of opportunities to take a relaxing stroll or soak up some sun. "Remember, acquiring good A/V gear takes lots of time...but doesn't necessarily take lots of money."

View Comments

  • Are there any significant new extras (cinematic history presentations is one of my professional research areas), compared to the BD release from some years ago? Also, is the BD from the new scan or is it simply a duplicate of the previous release? I ask because in the 4K release of Unforgiven, the BD copy is also taken from the new scan of Unforgiven and it is the only way to get the new scan on BD. I bought the 4K Unforgiven, despite being several years away from a 4K video capability in my home, specifically to get the new scan (I was relying on my HD DVD, until it experienced the same break down that almost all my other WB HD DVDs have had--though none of my non-WB discs have suffered so far, thankfully for my wallet).

    • Nothing really new here as the same supplements are ported over from previous home video release. The BD version included here is the same 2010 "Sapphire Edition" and not a new BD from the 4K scan, as far as I can tell.

Recent Posts

TAD Labs Introduces the Reference Series TAD-C700 Preamplifier

Major refinements inside and out have taken the already solid performer to the next level…

6 hours ago

AXPONA 2024 Show Coverage Part 2.

Welcome everyone to the second installment of our AXPONA 2024 coverage. Just to quickly reiterate,…

8 hours ago

Juke Audio Juke+ Streaming Multi-Zone Amplifier

Can you use the words simple and whole house audio in the same sentence? I…

1 day ago

Sennheiser Factory Tour

I got a chance to partake in an exclusive outing to Sennheiser's HQ in Tullamore…

2 days ago

Quad Revela 2 Floor-standing Speaker Review.

An elegant and buttoned-down loudspeaker that can still “kick it,” old school! Because of this…

3 days ago

Sonus faber Lumina II Amator Bookshelf Speaker Review

Sonus faber delivers high style and high performance from its Lumina II Amator Bookshelf Speakers.…

1 week ago