![]() |
![]() |
|||||
|
|
|||||
|
||||||
Wrap-Up
There was a lot to see this year at CES. I spent the bulk of my time in the North
Hall
talking to car audio manufacturers. Most of the manufacturers that I spoke to
were
very interested in our car project. Many were excited to see a more mature
approach
to car audio, and hope that we can represent them to a more affluent culture.
After
all there is more to car audio than 18" woofers and cars 6" off the
ground. - Brian Weatherhead -
CES 2003 was a mind-blowing event for a new writer at Secrets. I had previously been to a number of the Penta Heathrow Hi-Fi shows in London, but they certainly did not prepare me for CES. Penta is more like Alexis Park and T.H.E. Show, but the main activities of CES are at the incredibly large LVCC, which would fit 10 or so hotels into their main areas. Huge companies such as Hughes, Texas Instruments, Panasonic, Microsoft, Intel etc. all had large booths showing all of their latest products. Music and even actual video were only part of the show. However, I come from a long history of being an audiophile (a dirty word to some) but one, which I am proud of. I am not a believer in snake oil or little stones stuck around the room but I am one who believes that the sound of the music is all-important. I heard some beautiful music at CES. I had come prepared for bad sound, having read countless articles that talked about rooms which caused terrible bass, impossible dimensions, thin walls and other conditions that made the reproduction of music an incredibly difficult endeavor to succeed at. All I can say is that I heard some of the most beautiful music that I could have imagined. Alexis Park in particular did not seem to have difficulties with sound coming into one suite from another. I don't know whether this was because there were usually one or two rooms between each suite where music was playing or because the walls were relatively thick, but I was never disturbed there listening to music from one system and hearing sounds from another system down the hall. This was unfortunately not the case at T.H.E. Show that was held at the San Remo Hotel and where one could often hear music from one suite drifting into another. Even there however, I heard some of the most accurate and pellucid music it has been my privilege to ever hear. I am going to pick out some systems and some particular pieces of equipment that highly impressed me, for review in my own lab. However, I should state from the beginning that I did not by any means hear everything there was to hear at either Alexis Park or T.H.E. Show, nor did I have a chance to spend the time I would have liked in each room at either venue. I spent the first day at the LVCC and decided that it just wasn't my thing. I love video, but I am by no means an expert, I am no engineer, and my eyes are by no means as well trained as my ears. I have been listening to live music most of my life and have been an audiophile since 1979. When it comes to music, even though I am 52, I can still hear much of what is going on. I am lucky that my wife is 20 or so years younger than I am and she accompanied me through all three days at Alexis Park and San Remo. Together our ears heard the same things. I first want to comment upon the ubiquitous presence of Atma-Sphere tubed OTL (Output Transformer-Less) preamps and power amps in what seemed to be dozens of rooms, many of which sounded quite fine. I think there was a good reason for so many exhibitors choosing this brand. They seemed to be able to drive whatever the load was and their sound was beautiful to hear. I have never owned or listened to Atma-Sphere equipment for any length of time but with what I heard at the show, I will make it a point to review some of their equipment as soon as possible. If I had to choose a speaker which most impressed me and was within the possibility of owning it would be the new Dali Euphonia MS5. The Euphonia - depending upon finish are around $6,500/pair - is a 3.5 way configuration with a ribbon and soft dome wide dispersion tweeter module. It sounded alive, vivid and yet soft and gentle when needed. In other words, it shaped itself to the music, and yet everything that I heard played through these transducers had the characteristic of feeling alive and having an energy that drew one in. I am looking forward to reviewing these speakers as soon as possible. If they sound as good over a long review as they did in a 45 minute listening session, I might just have to find the money to buy them. The absolutely 'best speakers' I heard at the show were the Wisdom speakers with the new Wisdom amplification. Unfortunately these cost in the range of $240,000/pair, which is fantasyland for me, and I suspect for most of us. It was however, a thrill to listen to them for half an hour or so, just to know what can be created. I have neither the money, nor room to be able to even think about buying these beauties. However, I was told that some of their lesser siblings, which I didn't hear, also sounded superlative and might be worth a listen if you have a small fortune and not a large one. A listing of some other - and more sanely priced - speakers that impressed me would include the SoundLab Renaissance-3 (the Millennium-1s, were in far to small a room to sound very good), Phase Technology PC-9.1 Tower speakers which I was highly impressed with and were, if I remember correctly in the $7,000 range, which makes them at least a possibility. I enjoyed the sound of the Chesky Audio C-1, although I am not sure if they are presently available or are still simply being shown at shows, as they have been for the past year. I was also impressed with the Chateau Research Model 3 speaker that is time and phase aligned. Chateau was using their own pre and power amps, and the whole system sounded well balanced, with a clarity and sense of openness that was all too rare. The cables being used with the Chateau were the relatively new Empirical Audio power cables, interconnects and speaker cables. I am looking forward to hearing more of both Chateau and Empirical Audio cables. The small 12 inch Galante Symphony speakers sounded excellent along with the, I think the name was, VBT subwoofers. These tiny subwoofers sounded extraordinary and were just incredibly small. I was looking forward to hearing the new TAG McLaren pre/processor 192 but they didn't have it at the show. They have promised that after it is reviewed in Europe that they will make it available here for us to listen to. Just remember your promise guys! However TAG McLaren did have a new lifestyle system which sounded fine and sweet and which I have been promised to stick in my bedroom to audition in a situation where they most likely would be used. They run for about $9,000 for the Aphrodite, which combines a CD player, amplifier, and tuner and looks mighty sharp. They are partnered with the Calliope speakers, which are manufactured out of aluminum. The Calliope is available either passive or as an active speaker with a 100 Watt per driver amplifier. They are also available with a subwoofer as a stand or with their standard one. My wife was fairly drooling about having this set up in our bedroom. Another speaker that was extremely impressive and very inexpensive for what you get was the SLS Loudspeakers model HT8R. Its frequency response went from 44 Hz to 20,000 kHz +/- 2 dB, which is pretty good for a speaker that only costs $1,095/pair. It sounded great as a stereo speaker and it was also set up as a 5.1 multi-channel system where it fairly shone. The last speaker I wanted to mention was the Earthworks Sigma 6.2 Monitor that is a small time coherent near field reference monitor that goes down to about 40 Hz at -3 dB and up to 40 kHz -1 dB. They sounded superb sitting only 5 feet away. If you are forced to have your sound system in an extremely small room or are in the position to purchase a very expensive speaker system with your home computer, this speaker is certainly one to seriously consider. It costs around $6,000/pair, which is quite high, but I have to say that the sound was absolutely fantastic on the various SACD discs that I had them play. While I did not get a chance to hear the new Audio Design Associates Cinema Reference Mach II, what I saw of it and what it contained, it is certainly a pre/processor that I am looking forward to hearing. The unit contains 8 analog stereo inputs, 3 component video inputs, built in video processor, front panel color LCD preview monitor and the usual DD ED, DTS ES, PL-II, DTS Neo:6 and THX Ultra II modes. I did get a chance to hear Kimber's new Palladian Power Kords and was highly impressed, although I will need to hear them in my system to really assess their quality. All in all this was an exciting, exhausting experience, and I can't wait for CES 2004 so that I can get exhausted again. - Joshua Lerner -
At one point our illustrious Editor-in-Chief asked a few of us, "I hope you guys who have been to CES for a few years now aren't getting bored." No way, no how can anyone remotely interested in this stuff be board at CES, but I could see the reason for him asking: There was for the second year in a row, nothing "hot" or "new" in terms of technology, only new models, sometimes with improved specs but mostly just the proverbial bigger, better, badder! Before the show we spent a little time with some folks from the Paradigm Group because they were not actually exhibiting at CES. Big things coming from that company, none of which we are allowed to talk about yet. The first day we hit the floor running, trying to take in the scope of things. We talked with Andrew, one of Mirages designers, about the new OmniSat and Omni series speakers. He explained to us that despite the popularity of their Omnipolar speakers, they were loosing business at what some people consider the mid-fi price point. The reason was that Omnipolar technology requires double the drivers in any give speaker. The Omnisat concept allows them to get the same dispersion character as the Omnipolar models, with one tweeter and one mid-bass driver. Cool. Andrew also bragged up the BP-200 subwoofer, announced last year at CES but still not quite in our hands yet. According to him, the unit actually outperforms, by a margin, their legendary BPS-400. Well, we've just GOT to get our hands on one and see for ourselves.... Over at THX, it was business as usual: They showed a sampling of THX units which demonstrated the wide variety of products participating in the program. John Dahl explained to us that THX in car audio and multimedia/PC applications is VERY different from home theater. With the latter, everything is oriented towards adhering to established standards, with the end game being the proverbial "what the artist intended". When it comes to cars and PCs, there is no standard per sé so what THX is doing is leveraging their experience in the field and simply making things as good as they can be at a given price point. John also talked a little about Ultra2 in terms of speaker performance, telling us it is actually modeled after their PM3 spec which is the THX program for professional mixing facilities. Dolby had the Pro Logic II car again and at Roger Dressler's urging, we thought we'd better break down and actually listen. Pretty darn cool. Sandy wants one for his Pathfinder. The lines were indeed long to get into Faroudja's now renowned demos. Too bad there wasn't much to see this year. They used their DVD player on three different fixed pixel projectors, none of which impressed us. Over at Yamaha, the tables had turned. Two years ago I would not have put "Yamaha" and "Projector" in the same sentence but their two projectors, a pricey DLP and a reasonable LCD, were the best of their kind I saw at the show. The InFocus unit over at the TI display, in fairness, was every bit as good as the high end Yamaha. Also in the "way cool" department was Yamaha's MusicCast system which basically uses 802.11b to zip music through the house. Load all your tunes on the server, plug a couple speakers into the receiver and away you go. Panasonic, Sharp, Toshiba, Pioneer, Samsung, Zenith, and so on and so on.....were ALL pushing flat panel TVs ad nauseum. The plasmas still don't look good and the LCD models that are coming up in size, though looking marginally better, are priced where plasma was when it first came out. Further, what few RPTV models were being shown were mostly DLP and/or LCD inside. T'was a sad day for CRT. The most promising looking TV was from a company I thought wasn't around anymore: Proton. Well renowned in the interlaced TV days, they are back with a 34" 16:9 direct view which caught my attention when I saw you could turn off SVM in the user menu. Supposedly it will accept 480i, 480p, 1080i, and 720p on the component plugs and XGA on the RGB. Must get one for review... Atlantic Technology, as could be expected, have jumped on the THX Ultra2 bandwagon and we can say one thing: they are BIG speakers (as are any Ultra2 speakers we've seen). The finish on the units they showed was a definite improvement from what we've seen from Atlantic Technology in the past, though they may be racing the Ultra2 thing a little: They need four, count 'em, four of the pedestal subwoofers they had to meet spec. They had a prototype subwoofer with a 15" driver they say will meet Ultra2 spec on its own but as the saying goes "hearing is believing". All in all, there was with but a few exceptions a conspicuous lack of innovation at this years show. Comforting is the fact that 16:9 IS NOW THE SHAPE of TV. Makes us feel good for pushing 16:9 enhanced DVDs four years ago. - Brian Florian -
This year's CES was just as much fun as that of any of my visits. I didn't see any products that really broke much new ground, but rather a maturation of existing technologies. On the video front, digital displays of all kinds are looking less digital (a good thing.) Video processors are getting better as well. All of the digital video products are getting cheaper for a given performance level, but I think there's still progress to be made for the future benefit of consumers, and as of right now, I don't think there's any digital display available to consumers that can exploit the full potential of HD content. On the audio front, there's not much truly new, although existing technologies are being implemented in innovative ways. SSPs are interesting, and it was fun talking with the THX people about what is and isn't in their standards, as evasive and forthcoming as they may or not be without commitment but plenty of implication. The promise of a digital transmission standard for DVD-Audio content was exciting, though actual implementation is probably a year or two off. Loudspeakers are loudspeakers, in terms of new gizmos, but probably one of the most interesting points that demonstrations reminded me of was that CES and trade shows in general are a lousy environment for making product evaluations. Products which I've enjoyed thoroughly in my own home I'd consider abominable if I took their performance at manufacturer demonstrations as any indication of their own potential. It's also a fantastic excuse to request a review sample. The single greatest highlight for me, aside from listening to Cynthia rant like the amiable wonder wench that she is, was the talking to the manufacturers themselves about products, their design dilemmas, choices, and successes, as well as their considerations for future development and the market they negotiate as a means to eat. While this industry has more than it's share of phonies and hacks, there are also some genuinely interesting and conscientious people, which refreshes my interest in the field, as if my interest in the products weren't enough. And, there is of course, the sowing of seeds for future product reviews. Having heard so many promises in the past with little result, I've become somewhat conservative in making requests for review samples unless I'm particularly motivated with the prospect of using something. There were a few of those items, and discussions have ensued. We'll see what comes. - Colin Miller -
Having read CES reports in the past, I knew that the show was going to be big.
But reading about it is one thing, experiencing it is another! This was my
first trip to the show. The first day started with a long hike across the
hotel to take a shuttle to the South Hall, and a long hike through the South
Hall to the Press room. This was a preview of what was to come: walking long
distances and standing most of the day. On the bright side: there were going
to be plenty of toys to play around with, and exercise is good thing! Once we
reached the Press room, we looked at the floor layout of the various halls to
decide what we wanted to see. Off we went, and here is a summary of the days
spent at the show. - Sumit Chawla -
Another CES has passed and similar to last year there was a lack of exciting
new technology at least from the areas I explored. That said existing
technologies are being refined and improved particularly in the area of
digital front projection. Having been impressed by the crop of HD1 based DLPs
previously I was curious to see what improvement, if any, the new HD2 based
designs would yield. It would be foolhardy to place credit solely in the lap
of the HD2 chip as such a new technology receives performance boosts in other
areas. With that in mind the HD2 offerings by Marantz, DWIN, Yamaha and
InFocus were a definite step up from any of the HD1s I have spent time with.
Particularly impressive was the Marantz vp12s2 whose increase in lumens gave
the 100" diagonal 16:9 Firehawk the sufficient punch I felt was slightly
lacking in the initial iteration. An already respectable performer in the
contrast ratio department, the s2 takes another step forward in that area. My
fingers are crossed that the ever-helpful Dan Miller of Marantz can arrange a
review sample for one of our video gurus. - Chris Montreuil -
This was my first year at CES. The trip started off with a couple of
uneventful flights, which are always the best kind, followed by a hotel room
cable making session with our own Colin Miller. The day closed with an
excellent meal and some great discussions with guys from Paradigm. In
general, our days started out with a team meeting at the Grand Buffet, a great
spot to get some bacon for us Canadians. I spent most of my days in the main
conference center taking in demos from the leading manufactures in home audio
and video technology. I had originally planned to spend a large portion of my
time at Alexis Park where the high-end audio manufactures are, but that plan
changed as I found most of the manufactures I wanted to see, and considered
high-end, were in the main hall. Companies like Parasound, M&K, Bryston, etc.
were all located within the main conference center located with the other mass
market manufactured like Panasonic and sharp. For now let's talk about the
main conference center. I did go to Alexis, but we will save that for later.
There were still many great companies at Alexis that do put time into R&D and
build some exceptional products. Their prices are higher than mass market
gear. This is due to limited production runs and higher quality parts, both
internally and externally, used in their products. While I do not buy into
the hype of super high-end audio some of this equipment becomes a piece of
furniture as much as it is a functional audio component. There were speakers
with lacquer finishes so deep you could almost put your hand though them and
cabinetry work that would rival even the most elitist of cabinet makers. The
sound in the hotel rooms still left something to be desired, but was
substantially better than on the trade show floor back at the convention - Sandy Bird - Main | Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Wrap-Up
|