DVD Benchmark - Part 6 - DVD-Audio - November, 2001 (Updated March, 2005)
John Kotches, Don Munsil, Colin Miller, Brian Florian, and Stacey Spears
In mid-2000, after a long delay for a variety of issues, DVD-Audio (DVD-A) was given an inauspicious launch with the arrival of the first DVD-Audio players. It's been over a year since the first players have hit the market, and this marks our first foray into a background article explaining the technology behind DVD-Audio. This article will be split into several sections.
There is a lot of excitement surrounding DVD-Audio. At this time, musical artists are experimenting with multi-channel and speaker layouts. No longer is the artist limited by 2-channels. For those that might not be aware, stereo was actually intended to take up at least 3-channels of audio. Due to the limitation of the vinyl format, stereo was ultimately restricted to 2-channels. Not only are the artists experimenting with new channels, but they are trying different speaker layouts as you will read about below.
The results of all our Benchmark Tests are located HERE.
It's Digital Versatile Disc, and It Can Hold a Lot of Music!
There's plenty of argument over whether the DVD acronym is for Digital Video Disc or Digital Versatile Disc, but either way, the CD is miniscule in comparison. Each layer of a DVD can store approximately 4.37 GB, more than 7 times the capacity of the Compact Disc. Since DVD-A is about music, how much music data can you store? Well, a lot isn't descriptive, so here is a chart.
Sampling Depth Sampling Rate No. of Channels Time w/o MLP Time w/ MLP 24-Bit 96 kHz 5.1 N/A * 100 Minutes 24-Bit 96 kHz 6 N/A * 86 Minutes 24-Bit 96 kHz 2 150 Minutes 240 Minutes 24-Bit 192 kHz 2 75 Minutes 120 Minutes 16-Bit 44.1 kHz 2 420 Minutes 720 Minutes 16-Bit 44.1 kHz 1 840 Minutes 1500 Minutes
* Two of the formats exceed the allowable bandwidth off the drive as per the DVD specification (9.6 Mbit/second) so these formats carry an N/A. While it is possible to store 24-bit / 192 KHz without lossless compression, the discs we have access to at this time with 24-bit / 192 KHz data use MLP (Meridian Lossless Packing) compression, and we suspect that this will be the norm for all 24-bit / 192 KHz discs due to the extremely limited playback time without MLP.
We will delve into the details of what makes MLP tick later in this article.
Ingredients for a "Sort of Universal" DVD-Audio disc
In Part 3, we took a quick look the directory structures for DVD-Video (movies) discs, and touched on what the contents of a DVD-Audio disc would look like. DVD-Audio files are contained in files with extensions AOB (Audio Objects). This distinguishes them from their DVD-Video counterparts which are contained in files with extensions VOB (Video Objects). For example . . .
Figure 2 Figure 3
Figure 1 above is the root directory of Joni Mitchell's "Both Sides Now" DVD-A. As with the earlier examples, there are two folders, AUDIO_TS and VIDEO_TS. The AUDIO_TS is used by DVD-Audio players, while the VIDEO_TS folder is used for DVD-Video players. Some DVD-A players can emulate DVD-Video players for playing back DVD-A discs' DVD-Video tracks in the VIDEO_TS folder. Examples include the Onkyo DV-S939 and the Integra Research RDV-1 players. Both of these players have a setup option called Priority Content, which governs the behavior of the player when a DVD-Audio disc is inserted. Setting Priority Content to Audio/DVD-Audio (player dependent) means that the player will use the AUDIO_TS folder for content during DVD-Audio disc playback. Setting Priority Content to Video/DVD-Video (still player dependent) means the player will use the VIDEO_TS folder for content during DVD-Audio disc playback.
Figure 2 above is what the Video_TS directory looks like, and Figure 3 above shows the Audio_TS directory on "Both Sides Now". The directory structure for the two is similar, and the same constraints for file sizes (less than 1 GB per file) are in effect. The Video Manager runs the VIDEO_TS Files to display the menuing system for the disc. In this case, it's a simple menu, with one type of sound track (Dolby Digital). As with standard DVD-Video discs, multiple soundtracks are possible, with DD on every disc and DTS on some discs.
The entire contents of the DD-encoded music are contained within VIDEO_TS.VOB, with 44 minutes or so of material and the images required being stored within that single file.
Contrast the small storage requirements with the DVD-Audio portion of the disc. As before, the AUDIO_TS files are used by the Audio Manager, and the ATS series of files with the AOB extension contains the DVD-Audio content. Note that the 44 minutes of DVD-Audio material takes up approximately 4 GB of data for the same program. The latest Warner Brothers releases I've purchased are shipping with dedicated 5.1 and stereo mixes, rather than relying on the MLP decoder core to do a fold-down to stereo. The DVDAUDIO files are the credits for the DVD Audio disc, which is a series of still images with text overlays and menu options.
Like DVD-Video, DVD-Audio makes use of the Top Menu (a.k.a. Title Menu) button. Here are the results (Figure 4a below) on a PC, which behaves as a DVD-Video player:
When you insert the disc, the audio soundtrack selection is made. Notice the segregation between DVD-Video and DVD-Audio players? You get a different Top Menu when you insert this disc into a DVD-Audio player. In this Top Menu, you select your soundtrack before you're moved off to the Video Menu (Our term).
Access to the MLP 5.1 Surround track is blocked on my PCs software DVD player and on my DVD-Audio player when Priority Content is set to Video.
Figure 4a Top Menu Figure 4b Video Menu
Figure 4b (above) illustrates the video menu, where you can select the various options. The Tracks/Lyrics selection encompasses four separate titles, Title 1, which is the DTS 5.1 soundtrack without lyrics, just a background image, Title 2, the DTS 5.1 soundtrack with lyrics for each track, Title 3 is DD 2.0 with background image only, and Title 4 is DD2.0 with lyrics for each track. Title 5 is the music video.
It's necessary to split the song versions with lyrics from the song versions without into separate groups, as DVD-Video playback is not designed to allow browsing of content during playback - so the Lyrics option is offered as a separate group which displays a static image.
Shown below (Figure 5) is a directory listing of the VIDEO_TS folder; you can see there are six titles in this folder. See above for the descriptions of all but Title 6, which is another copy of the Dolby Digital 2.0 encoded track.
Figure 5 Figure 6
The DVD-Audio behavior (Figure 6, shown above) is interesting as well - there are four groups (title equivalent for DVD-A) accessible, Group 1 is DVD-A playback, Group 3 is DTS 5.1 playback. Group 4 gives DD 2.0 playback, and Group 5 is the music video. You might notice that the ATS (DVD-Audio playback files) are the only contents in this folder. To save space, and not duplicate the data, links to titles within the VIDEO_TS folder are used to access DTS, DD and the Music Video titles.
DTS so far is the only content provider allowing you to switch between DVD-Audio / DTS / Dolby Digital tracks without changing the default behavior of the player. I give kudos to them for what I consider to be correct implementation, which allows for comparison between the various tracks.
Bass (mis)Management and (no) Time Alignment:
We outlined this topic in the audio review on the Onkyo DV-S939 DVD-Audio player. Right now, Bass management for DVD-Audio players is non-existent, and most consumers don't have the luxury of five full range (or nearly so) loudspeakers. None of the DVD-A players we've worked with has provided bass management for DVD-Audio material. We've had several discussions on this topic, and the word is that as of this writing, DSPs have insufficient processing power to handle MLP unpacking and also handle the crossover arithmetic in the digital domain. In the future, DSPs will have sufficient power. Digital Standards (non-proprietary) are in the works, and once this hits the marketplace, the Preamp/Processor (or Receiver) will handle bass management as it does for DD/DTS and CDs.
All of DVD-A players we have worked with included Dolby Digital Decoding, and some of them also included DTS decoding.
There are products coming to market to handle bass management for all five channels, such as the Outlaw ICBM-1. Be warned that there's info out there that's full range in all channels on some of the discs out there. Take Steely Dan's Two Against Nature -- great material, and they have electric bass across all five speakers on this disc on most tracks.
So we've got to address bass management outside of the DVD-A player, because we don't have it available to us on the analog outputs of the player. There are ways to work around this, but it takes some effort.
The solution makes a few assumptions about the capabilities of your subwoofer. First, it can accept both high and low-level inputs. Second, it has an LFE input. This input is direct to the amplifier without engaging the internal crossover. You really need two inputs, but one is acceptable; just install a Y adapter to work around this limitation.
With this scenario, the front left and right channels are sent via speaker level inputs, and the subwoofers internal crossover is used. From here, the speaker level inputs get routed to the front left and right speakers, with all low frequencies removed.
Use of the LFE input is vital, as you don't want have multiple crossovers (three channels + subwoofers) working simultaneously on the same audio streams.
In Figure 7 below is a line level diagram of more than one product that will be entering the market shortly to assist with bass management for DVD-A (and multi-channel SACD) players which have no bass management for their high-resolution outputs.
A well designed 5-channel crossover unit will have 3 discrete crossover settings, for Front L/R Channels, Center Channel, and Surrounds. A single global crossover point would be functional, but just barely, since most consumers don't have 5 matched speakers.
Additionally, this will require two sets of interconnects (yes that's 12 cables) for going into and out of the crossover.
That tangled snarl of cables behind your system is going to get even worse than it already is!
This method gives a summed output for the subwoofer, which also includes the discrete 0.1 track should it be on the recording. We have seen some DVD-A discs that are 5.0 (no subwoofer / LFE track).
On a related to bass management topic, John Kotches was involved in a series of discussions about bass management with the Panasonic RP-91 for DVD-Audio discs at the AVS Forum. One thing that was learned in the process by more than one person is that some receivers (or processors for that matter) will do some unexpected bass management. This unexpected bass management is in the form of sampling the incoming analog signal into the digital domain, applying the defined crossover, and sending out the subwoofer signal. The original signal is not altered, and is passed along to the speakers.
Another function provided by our HT processors is Time Alignment. This compensates for differences in speaker distances so that the sound from each speaker arrives at the listening position at the right moment in time (the same time). For digital formats, your Preamp/Processor (or receiver) will provide time alignment of the drivers based on your input. So why do we even need time alignment of our speakers?
Consider John Kotches listening room - diagrammed in Figure 8 below. We have left out the popcorn machine, candy machine, and soda pop dispenser for the sake of simplicity. The speakers are anywhere from 5.5 feet (subwoofers) to 8.5 feet (front left + right) from his listening position. If sound is emitted from all speakers simultaneously, the sounds won't arrive at his ears simultaneously. Each foot of difference in distance corresponds to roughly one millisecond in time. If you really want to delve into it, it's a little more than one foot (1130 ft/second at sea level at one atmosphere of pressure, with a specified temperature and humidity). If we want all these sounds to be coincident at our ears, we have to have some mechanism for delaying the signals from the speakers farther away as required. This is yet another function handled by DSPs in our receivers / processors. In his case, the sounds from the subwoofers would be delayed by about 3 milliseconds, the surrounds by about 2 milliseconds, and the center by about 1.5 milliseconds to make everything coincident.
Time alignment isn't just about making the sounds coincident! It's also necessary to keep the time relationship between speakers accurate so that things like hall reverberation (on music recordings) and other sonic characteristics remain properly aligned in time.
Once again, due to insufficient horsepower in the current generation of DSPs, time alignment isn't being performed on DVD-A material. So for multi-channel recordings, we aren't hearing everything quite like it was intended.
There's a lot of commotion about the “requirement” of having a display device to set into motion DVD-Audio playback. We are writing to dispel that notion. Quite simply put, it isn't true. While it might be necessary to use a display for speaker level calibration (this is dependent on the player – it is possible for the player to give visual cues on its on LED panel), that's the extent of the monitor's requirement. Inducing playback of a disc can be accomplished by more than one method; none of them requires the use of a monitor.
If your player's operating firmware is implemented correctly, Warner Brothers titles (and their affiliated labels) can be started by inserting the disc into the tray, and hitting the Play button. This will initiate immediate playback following reading of the player's Table of Contents (TOC). There is one caveat to this method: you will get the default soundtrack datastream, which happens to be the multi-channel one. Warner's first round of titles (including kd lang's "invincible summer" and Emerson, Lake and Palmer's "Brain Salad Surgery") had only the multi-channel track and stereo reproduction via the fold-down instructions within the MLP data. Subsequent releases (and possible newer pressings of the above two tracks) include both the multi-channel and dedicated stereo mixes. This was confirmed on multiple discs by the mastering engineer Bob Ludwig, of Gateway Mastering. Thankfully, WB has implemented identical menu structures on all of these discs, so once you know the menu layout for one title, you know it for all of them. It so happens that the multi-channel mix is listed first in the menu, then the stereo mix. When the player loads the disc and pulls up the Top Menu, you will be greeted with a long pause. During this pause, all you need to do is hit the <down> arrow on your cursor keypad, followed by <select> and then <Play> twice. The 1st time you hit play, you are transferred to the stereo track listing. The 2nd time, you begin playback of the disc.
What we would really like to see is the automatic initiation of playback for all discs, so that even these gyrations are not needed to begin playback; simply insert the disc and hit the <close> or <play> buttons, and playback would initiate. Some record labels are already delivering their discs with automatic playback enabled. Hats off to Silverline and Audionet for authoring their titles this way! This is much more what the user is expecting. If you're patient, almost all titles will eventually auto-play, but it can take up to 45 seconds for playback to begin without any input from you. There is one notable exception: DTS' DVD-Audio titles are not starting automatically, so you must select between the DVD-A, DTS, or DD soundtrack before playback will begin.
Improving playback usability isn't limited to this problem. It would be nice to be able to define a default mix (a.k.a. datastream) or even a hierarchy of them. When this default mix is available, the player would begin playback without intervention. Otherwise, the disc's default mix could be engaged. This would be a welcome addition, especially for those who will (or can) only listen to stereo mixes for music.
Along a similar vein, there are some discs, where the downmix flag is set to “disallow”, which means your playback must match the channel configuration of the recording. If it does not, you'll be missing information from channels that are not configured in your system. This works against the DVD-A format, since not all audiophiles want to listen to music in surround. Like it or not, it's a shortcoming that should be addressed by content providers.
There is another interesting feature when it comes to some DVD-Audio players, the ability to set the Priority Content. What this does is change the personality of the player between DVD-Video and DVD-Audio. When set to DVD-Video, the player will behave exactly as a DVD-Video player, and when presented with a DVD-Audio disc, it will read the VIDEO_TS folder (just as a DVD-Video player would). When set to DVD-Audio, it will read the AUDIO_TS folder when presented with a DVD-Audio disc. I'm not sure why someone would want to force a DVD-Audio player into DVD-Video player behavior, but some players do provide this capability. (This would be useful for a test disc where you stored test patterns and test tones for video in Video_TS and test tones for audio in Audio_TS. – Stacey–)
Lest you think we dislike DVD-Audio, we say . . . not so! In fact, we think it is a tremendous improvement over Redbook CD, and the best recordings on DVD-A certainly could make you wonder just what all the fuss is about the competing high-resolution format. For recordings which are truly mastered in 24- bit / 96 kHz (which means the entire recording chain all the way to the disc stays at 24-bit / 96 kHz), the sound is nothing short of spectacular. Take a listen to titles from AIX, Silverline, and Chesky and you'll understand what we mean.
DVD-A and the Speaker Babylon (or How a Flexible Standard Can Cost You So Much Money!)
This section is an expansion on MLP. MLP's metadata is very rich, which can (and does) carry information regarding the channel configuration.
DVD-Audio is a highly flexible format, with a variety of channel configurations available, from monophonic to 6 channels running full range at 24 bit sampling depth, and 96 kHz sampling.
The “standard” format for DVD-Audio is the 5.1 mix, which all of you are already familiar with. But anyway, here is a diagram of the recommended speaker configuration for multi-channel installations (Figure 9, below). This is an important frame of reference to keep in mind for the subsequent configurations discussed below. Going straight out the listeners eyes to the front of the room defines the 00 reference for all angles.
Figure 9a ITU 5.1 2D Layout Figure 9b ITU 5.1 3D Layout
In this layout, all channels are defined as full range, along with a dedicated Low Frequency Effects (a.k.a. the 0.1) channel. All speakers are equidistant from the primary listening position, with the main left and right speakers at the point of an equilateral triangle. The center speaker is on an arc, so that it is dead center on the listener (duh!). Surrounds are located at 1100 behind the listener. This is slightly behind the listening position, as opposed to directly opposite the listening position (900).
What ends up in the 0.1 channel is solely at the discretion of the mixing engineer, and this can be anything from kick drums to bass guitar to pipe organs. All speakers are equidistant from the primary listening position, with the main left and right speakers at the points of an equilateral triangle. The surrounds are placed at an angle of 1100 to the rear of the listening position.
In an ideal world, all the speakers are equidistant, and in the real world, we need delay settings. The rule of thumb is one millisecond (ms) for every 1 foot of difference in displacement. Without this time alignment, the soundstage can be compromised, which means DVD-Audio can't reach its maximum sonic potential.
The above diagram is an example of a real room, with distances and speaker layouts displayed. In this room, the speakers are not equidistant. If the DVD-Audio player in use required millisecond inputs, we'd have to “normalize” to the longest distance. In this case, that would be the 8'6” distance to the mains. To time align the center channel, a delay of 1.5 ms is added to the Center Channel setting. Continuing on, the surrounds require a 2 ms delay, and the LFE channel requires a 3 ms delay. Once these values are configured in your DVD-A player, voila`, you're finished. Note: Many DVD-A players don't support time alignment for DVD-A outputs, only Dolby Digital and DTS decoded outputs. We expect this to be supported in a future generation of DVD-A players.
If the limitation for the processor is 1ms increments (most common case), try both 1 and 2ms and see which sounds best in your room. Our experience is that the higher value will work better.
A Common Variation
Some mixes (classical and an isolated track or two of popular music) are in 5.0, which skips the 0.1 channel. Most orchestral music doesn't have tremendous amounts of low frequency information, with the exception of bass drum hits. For example, the String Bass has a lowest frequency of approximately 41 Hz, while the lowest note on the standard piano keyboard (referred to as A0) is 27.5 Hz.
Outside the realm of classical DVD-Audio discs, most mainstream label material is presented in 5.1 format. A rare exception to this are two tracks from Emerson, Lake and Palmer's "Brain Salad Surgery", tracks Benny the Bouncer and Still You Turn Me On. Oddly enough, the rest of the disc is 5.1.
Raising the Roof of Your Listening Room
At CEDIA 2001, we were treated to a demonstration of an alternative 6-channel configuration for DVD-Audio: the inclusion of height channels. Rather than go into a long speech about the demonstration, I'll (JK) just say that for the first time I experienced the full acoustic space of a venue. It was so good, I showed up early two days in a row to hear the demonstration.
An underplayed feature of MLP is the able to carry within the metadata (everything that isn't the audio) the channel configurations. Should a non-standard speaker configuration be presented, the metadata can indicate so. DVD-A players or processors (when the signal can be transmitted digitally) with sufficient outputs could theoretically route outputs based on the channel configuration. This ties in to the inclusion of height channels nicely, and there are a few configurations out there in the market.
We'll start off with the easiest of them, the Telarc height channel. In the Telarc configuration, you begin with the standard 5.0 speaker layout of Front L/R/C and Rear L/R. The subwoofer channel is reallocated to the height channel (Figure 10a). The height channel has two potential solutions. A single channel can be located directly above the center channel for a 6.0 solution.
Figure 10a Telarc Height 2D Layout Figure 10b Telarc Height 3D Layout
Alternately, two channels can be utilized to present height information (Figure 10b). In this configuration, the two channels are placed at the sides of the listening position, well above the plane of the other speakers. In both cases, the information presented in the height channel is identical; the two speaker solution affords a more diffuse presentation of the height information. In Telarc's multi-channel mixing room, dual height channels are employed using dipolar radiating planar magnetic loudspeakers (Figure 11, below). The speakers are wired in series, so a single channel of amplification can drive them.
Figure 11a Alternate Telarc 2D Layout Figure 11b Alternate Telarc 3D Layout
Of course, just to keep things interesting, there has to be more! And in fact there are two more configurations to cover. First is the 2+2+2 format, being brought out by MDG records in Germany. In this setup, the center and subwoofer channels are redirected for use as left and right height channels respectively. The height channels are placed literally above the main left and right speakers. Below (Figure 12), you will find an image of the MDG 2+2+2 format.
Figure 12a Height 2+2+2 2D Layout Figure 12b Height 2+2+2 3D Layout
Our journey through speaker Babylon is nearly complete. We come now to Chesky's 6.0 format, which includes front / side height channels which is similar to an earlier mentioned format that attempts to build a more spacious sensation when listening in this fashion. In a conversation with David Chesky, he stated that his height channel recordings will only be exclusive to the DVD-A format.
In the Chesky configuration (Figure 13, below), height channels are placed above and outside the main speakers at approximately 55 degrees. Having heard this example it is most impressive in truly conveying the sensation of space within a recording venue.
Figure 13a Height 6.0 2D Layout Figure 13b Height 6.0 3D Layout
All of the alternative surround layouts are intended for one thing: to improve the illusion that you are in a real space (the recording venue).
Making it All Work in Your Home Theater
So . . . how do you hook this all up? There are several options, and the logistical issues of relocating speakers as required is something we will get into at another time and date. It's either that or purchase several more speakers! We have drawn three diagrams (Figures 14, 15, and 16, below) which will show you how to cover most of the system possibilities out there, even ours.
In all cases, the speaker level outputs for the CC (5th) and the 6th channel will go to the switchbox common inputs, left and right respectively.
The simplest configuration assumes you are using the same speakers for the Chesky and MDG surround setups. It requires a two-way switchbox, with output A handling standard 5.1 setups and the Telarc height channel. During 5.1 listening, no signal will be present on the 6th channel. For Telarc height, the subwoofer line level cable would need to be connected to the 6th channel amplifier input. A switchbox could be employed for this as well.
Figure 14 Two-way Switchbox
If you want to start getting really serious about this, you could dedicate separate speakers (or at least speaker wires) to the different configurations. In this case you need a three-way speaker box. Output A would be for 5.1 and Telarc listening, with the Telarc height channel inactive for 5.1 listening. Output B goes to the Chesky height channel speakers, and Output C goes to the DMG height speakers.
Figure 15 Three-way Switchbox
Of course as a reviewer I can't do things that straight forward, so I'm (JK) legally required to make things vastly more complicated in my system (only kidding). In my system, I have an unpowered subwoofer, and my 6th amplification channel drives the subwoofer for 5.1 listening. To fully do all the height options, I'd have to go to a four-way switchbox. The outputs in my system would be as follows: Output A for 5.1 listening with the left channel connected to the center, and the right channel connected to the subwoofer. For Telarc listening, I'd use output B, with the left channel going to the center and the right channel going to the height channel(s). For Chesky Listening, I'd use output C, with the left channel going to left height, and the right channel going to right height. For MDG listening, I'd use output D, with left channel going to left height and right channel going to right height.
Figure 16 Four-way Switchbox
And now our journey to Speaker Babylon has come to an end. Please exit from the front doors and watch your step.
Information Gathered and Tests Executed During Benchmark-2 (B2) for Analysis of Audio Performance
There were several tests that every player passed at our B2. None of the players included in this event were SACD capable, and all were able to correctly read the CD layer of a hybrid SACD. All DVD-Video players correctly accessed the DVD-Video content on a DVD-Audio disc. All players passed both tracks with simulated fingerprints (tracks 18 and 19). This test was done via listening, and the key part with this test is not that there are no errors in the process, rather that there are no audible errors. None of the players did buffering (cache the key presses from a user) of chapter to chapter jumps on DVD-Audio discs. With some DVD-Video players, you can rapidly hit the Next Chapter button and rapidly switch through.
For players that included Dolby Digital decoders, we recorded information on bass management for them: Size adjustments, delay, and subwoofer settings were recorded, and the AVIA bass sweep was used to determine the crossover frequency for engaged bass management. Of the DVD-A players, tested none of the players had bass management capability for DVD-A material. No player tested engaged crossovers for Redbook CD playback. In addition, we noted whether the player included a night compression mode for Dolby Digital.
We noted which players indicated ability to play HDCD discs, and where visual indicators were available, confirmed with an HDCD disc that the content was being detected, and the appropriate filter engaged.
The second Benchmark Event (B2) was held at Stacey's house, and we had the whole house rocking with various and sundry tests. Because Stacey's main HT room was tied up with video tests, we had to assemble a system for use in critical listening. John Kotches took over one of the bedrooms to do the listening, and some of the audio tests.
Hot on the heels of JJs review of the Diva 4.1s, AV123.com shipped us a matched quintet of Model 5.1s for use in listening during the review. The finish on these speakers looked marvelous, and after some break-in, they sounded pretty good too. They won't convert John Kotches over from being a planar nut, but they are excellent, musical speakers. On the other hand, they did point out the importance of having a matched quintet of speakers and how costly this may be for most. Pans on a matched set of fives is never a question about differences in speakers; it's all about room placement (the biggest factor anyway) and components. A hearty thanks to AV123.com (and Mark Schifter) for the loan of the speakers.
The subwoofer was a Von Schweikert Tower of Power, which was both John Kotches' and Stacey Spears' reference subwoofer until the SV Subwoofers displaced them, so we are familiar with their performance from the years it served as our subwoofer's.
The brains and brawn of the system was the Integra DTR-9.1 A/V Receiver. This product has its own review, so we are not going to repeat information here other than to say it did yeoman's work on a variety of different configurations, working flawlessly for us.
Cabling for all components was by Nordost: Red Dawn Analog interconnects and speaker cabling and their Moonglo digital cable. These models of cables have been used by many of the Secrets staff so we are familiar with their characteristics.
Power conditioning was provided by the PS Audio Power Plant 600 - We didn't do any work with multi-wave options due to time constraints, and all components were fed with 60 Hz Sine Wave.
We tried to damp the first reflection points for the speakers using ASC Planar traps - these normally reside in Stacey's main system, which was handling video-only chores, so they weren't needed.
Speaker calibration was done with an Audio Control SA-3051, Spectrum Analyzer (1/3 octave Real Time Analyzer) and SPL meter using a calibrated microphone.
Selections John Kotches Used for Listening observations
One of the ways we tried to expand the scope of B2 was to include listening observations on players used for the Benchmark as appropriate and as time permitted. Since I did the listening observations, I wanted to write a few words on the various recordings I used, and most of these are from my personal Reference Discs. This is a somewhat liquid list of discs, and includes DVD-A, Redbook CD, HDCD, DTS, and DD encoded formats. The goal was to provide a cross section of materials within the confines of my taste and provide some brief subjective impressions of some of the players under test for the benchmark. Looking back over my notes, I don't remember writing as much as I did, but this is beneficial to our readership!
Redbook CD Recordings:
Bob Mintzer Big Band, Camouflage, Track 3 Long Ago and Far Away
This is a tenor feature ballad and I listen for a few things along the way. First and foremost the tone of the leaders horn with both rhythm section and as he rides over the top of the band at the songs closing. Additionally, as the tenor solo builds, there's a section where the trombone and trumpet sections build backing chords with bell tones. This starts with the trombone section hitting one note, with one player holding, 3 trombonists hitting the next note, then 2 trombonists and finally 1. As this section progresses the trumpets do a similar treatment.
The drumkit on this is from left of center to right of center, without exaggeration of the width of the soundstage.
Joni Mitchell, Mingus, Track 11 Goodbye Porkpie Hat
This song is Mingus' tribute to great Tenor Saxophonist Lester Young, and Joni does her rendition with an all star backing group including Jaco Pastorius on Bass, Wayne Shorter on Saxophones and Peter Erskine on Drums. Mostly I listen for the brushes on the drums and Joni's vocal qualities. I can't say as I'm a fan of Jaco's playing on this disc, as it's too overbearing, but that's a personal preference.
I also use this track as a test of HDCD decoding, as it is an HDCD encoded disc.
Keith Jarrett, The Melody at Night With You, Track 8 Shenandoah
This is a traditional American folk song, and this is a lovely rendition. I'm listening for the naturalness of the piano sound - whether I can hear Keith vocalizing or not, and finally, the decay of the last chord. I want to hear every nanosecond of that gorgeous dissonance that he has voiced. It brings a smile to my face when I hear this fade away acoustically into nothingness. It beats the heck out of an artificial decay!
DVD with Linear PCM Soundtrack
The Eagles, Hell Freezes Over, Track 16 The Last Resort
A hidden, often unused reference is on the concert DVD - a full PCM stereo soundtrack, which is of exceptional quality. We often skip over this well done gem to get at the DTS encoded surround track. I use this when I'm testing DACs out pretty regularly. I'm listening for a few things with this track - first and foremost it's the quality of the Yamaha MidiGrand and how wrong it sounds. The better the playback gear the worse this thing sounds. I listen to the quality of the strings, and Don Henley's vocals to hear how much sibilance is present, and how the vocal quality changes at the top of his register before breaking into falsetto at the close of the track.
Some of my audiophile friends consider me to be a bit of a heathen, because I like immersive style surround mixes where I'm placed in the middle of the band. This comes from my youth when I spent many an hour in the middle of the band!
DTS has done a fabulous job in taking some familiar material and encoding them onto Compact Discs. Also, some of the best sounding Concert DVDs to my ears have DTS encoded tracks. Here's what I listen to:
Lyle Lovett, Joshua Judges Ruth, Track 8, Baltimore
This may be the best DTS encoded CD out there, and I hope DTS can get the rights to release this as a DVD-Audio disc. This one is a fairly simply orchestrated track, with voice, guitar, piano, and cello if memory serves me correctly. Sometimes the simplest is the toughest to reproduce. I'm listening for the nuances here - the noises of Lyle's mouth as he completes some phrases. The edge (yes edge) that the recording takes on (almost certainly intentional) in certain places is an excellent contrast to the gentleness exhibited by other passages.
Alan Parsons, On Air, Track 9, So Far Away
This disc was intended for 5.1 treatment from the start, and as such makes aggressive use of surrounds. Chris Cross is the featured vocalist and his particularly smooth voice as well as the interplay on harmonizations is a treat. On a standout recording it's hard to pick one track, but the combination of lead and harmony vocals, and the variety of instruments is both enjoyable and to me revealing of components in the system.
The Police, The Singles, Track 7 Every Little Thing She Does is Magic
So many little details in layer upon layer on this track. Vocals, pianos (is that a vocoder? on the bridge). I've always known this was a fairly complex textured selection, but the 5.1 mix emphasizes this aspect. This track also has Stewart Copeland's drum kit all over the place, and so, this track does a fine job of showing a DTS decoder's ability to deliver transients.
Fun stuff, and the out chorus is a "high volume required" item in my system at home!
Dolby Digital Decoding
I only use one test track for DD decoding, as the majority of my reference material is DTS or DVD-A encoded.
James Taylor, Live at the Beacon Theater, Track 6 Only a Dream in Rio
This is the only track I used for testing the Dolby Digital prowess of a player. On this track I listen for the sound of JTs voice and guitar, which should be solidly placed in the center channel. Can you hear the details of his plucking clearly - on the best players you can tell when his thumb and his fingers pluck as they have mildly different timbres. Background vocalists should spread from left to nearly dead center. How is the timbre of the guitar in the right channel? How clear (and powerful) is the bass line?
As alluded to earlier, I'm a bit unusual in the audiophile community with respect to my enjoyment of surround music. I wonder how many audiophiles realize that for the vast majority of recordings the soundstage and imaging that they so love to talk about is all in the hands of the mixing engineer? There are certainly exceptions, but for the most part this is controlled by a pot on the mixing console.
Between this and my background as a musician, I'm not averse to sounds coming at me from all directions. Last time I checked, this happens in the real world too!
I've been acquiring DVD-A discs over the past several months and am currently using some of these in my collection as reference discs:
Joni Mitchell, Both Sides Now, Track 5 Answer Me, My Love
Forget about anything else - the brass choir that opens this selection is absolute ear candy! Joni is expressive in this cut, and she manages to both "belt out" as needed, and treat other passages with a wonderful delicacy. Wayne Shorter sticks the bell of his soprano saxophone into this one, and at one point has some spittle in his mouthpiece - you can tell what's going on there! Strings sound like they're real, as does the brass section, which is nicely featured in this track.
kd lang, Invincible Summer, Track 2 Summer Fling
This one is a lilting, medium tempo number, and it's kd multi-tracked for the background vocals. If it's not obvious who's singing background vocals, you have a problem somewhere. In addition, the "disco strings" (that's how I describe the texture / sound) are real, not synthesized, and if it's not immediately apparent, the player is lacking in resolution. Synthesizer counterpoint used in several sections should be fixed in space, and solid. Any wavering indicates an issue with imaging on the player.
Blue Man Group, Audio, Track 2 PVC IV
This disc has tremendous energy. It's tribal / world music / just plain fun! Things can be a little repetitive, and they often take a sequence and build layers upon a simple foundation. It's a lot of percussive instruments, with PVC used to make many of the sounds. The instruments are home made and take on interesting and unique tonalities.
I'm not sure where the ideas came up for the various concoctions of PVC piping and mallets to strike them originated, but all this disc does is make me want to attend the show. Hey JJ -- let's get tickets for 2002 CES for one of their shows at the Luxor now! I know you wanted this disc being the bass fiend you are, but I won't part with it! Get your own copy editor dude!
So what do I listen for on this track? The roundness of the PVC marimbas as they're struck. Because the paddles are flat, you get a kind of an "oh" sound from the tubes. The crackle of the drum well across the soundstage, from rear right to front left. The quality of the bass notes out of the PVC pipes. The energy delivered as the piece reaches its climax, then fades down. Is the forward momentum sustained?
Please consider all of my listening sessions as the preliminary impressions they are - time did not permit listening to any of the players to anywhere near the amount we would have liked.
This article joins the previous five in order to round out the DVD technology. It is our first attempt, and like the other articles, will grow and improve over time. If you find new issues or suggestions in regards to DVD-A, please e-mail the staff at Secrets, and we might use it in updates to the article.
- John Kotches, Don Munsil, Colin Miller, Brian Florian, and Stacey Spears -
1. Alastair Roxburgh, EAD Corporation, Chief Technical Officer. Alastair gave permission to use diagrams from Theatermaster-8 manual which we modified to help build our own versions.
2. David Chesky, Chesky Records. David and John Kotches had some e-mail discussions about Chesky's 6.0 channel setup. We wanted to confirm that our understanding was correct prior to committing this article to print.
3. Michael Bishop, Telarc Records, Chief Mixing Engineer. Michael confirmed that we indeed understood the correct configuration and reasoning behind dual height channels in Telarcs surround sound mixing room.
4. Manfred Görgen, '2+2+2 Information for installation the HiFi-Equipment', MDG.
5. Manfred Görgen, '2+2+2 - Recording "Breakthrough into a new dimension"', MDG.
6. JR Stuart, PG Craven, MA Gerzon, MJ Law, RJ Wilson, 'MLP Lossless Compression', AES 9th Regional Convention Tokyo 1999. Available for download at http://www.meridian-audio.com/w_paper/mlp_jap_aes9_1.PDF
7. RJ Wilson, 'DVD-Audio, with a focus on MLP', AES Singapore July 2000.
8. Meridian Audio, "Meridian MLP Encoder User Guide".
If you want to license our Benchmark explanatory articles for use in your company, please send an e-mail to our staff.
DVD Benchmark - Technical Article Index
Part 1 - Video Part 2 - Audio Part 3 - Functionality Part 4 - Usability Part 5 - Progressive Scan Part 6 - DVD Audio
© Copyright 2001 Secrets of Home Theater & High Fidelity
Return to Table of Contents for this Issue.